Public health agencies face constant challenges that require innovative solutions. From emerging infectious diseases and environmental health threats to chronic disease prevention and health equity issues, these agencies must adapt and evolve their approaches to protect and promote public health. The COVID-19 pandemic highlighted the critical need for innovation in public health systems as agencies rapidly developed and implemented new disease surveillance, communication, and intervention strategies.
Innovation in public health extends beyond developing pioneering technology or implementing the latest trends. It is a broad concept that can occur at multiple levels within an organization or system. These innovations can be technological, cultural, or procedural, and often involve collaboration across disciplines and sectors. The key is that innovation represents significant improvements or new approaches to addressing public health issues, regardless of scale or form. Examples of innovation in public health can include:
- New or improved interventions for public health practitioners
- Enhanced processes for existing workflows
- New ways of communicating with partners and the public
- Creative problem-solving approaches to tackle pressing public health challenges
- Collaborative efforts that break down silos and promote knowledge sharing
Public health agencies across the nation share common challenges when it comes to fostering innovation. The complexity and constraints of public health systems can create significant barriers to implementing new ideas and approaches. However, by recognizing these common challenges, public health agencies can develop strategies to overcome them and create a more innovation-friendly culture.
Common contributing factors to these challenges include:
threat_intelligence
Risk aversion: Public health agencies often face intense scrutiny from the media, policymakers, and the public, leading to a culture of caution in which trying new approaches is seen as potentially risky.
payments
Funding limitations: Many public health agencies struggle with chronic underfunding and budget constraints. This can make it challenging to invest in innovative projects or technologies.
desktop_cloud_stack
Complex systems: The decentralized nature of the U.S. public health system and varying structures across federal, state, territorial, and local levels can complicate implementing new ideas and make it challenging to scale innovations.
hourglass_empty
Time constraints: Staff often lack dedicated time for innovation amidst day-to-day responsibilities, which can limit their capacity for creative thinking and problem-solving.
domain_disabled
Organizational barriers: Existing organizational cultures may not support or encourage innovative thinking. This can be particularly challenging in agencies with long-standing traditions and established working methods.
analytics
Data silos: Fragmented data systems and lack of interoperability can impede the kind of data sharing and analysis that often drives innovation.
Public health agencies recognize the need to foster innovation to address complex health challenges more effectively. By embracing a broader definition of innovation and creating supportive environments, agencies are finding new ways to improve public health outcomes.
On July 11, 2024, ASTHO hosted the INSPIRE Readiness: Innovating in Public Health Systems webinar. The webinar focused on innovating public health systems, unique approaches to system advancement, and navigating environments that support new practices. This innovation story explores factors challenging innovation and offers strategies for creating a culture of innovation in public health organizations, drawing on insights from the webinar panelists.
"When I think about innovation, it's really a willingness to disrupt the traditional ways that we do things in order to really find new and improved ways of addressing the emerging health threats and existing health threats that our communities face."
- Nathan Weed, Chief of Resilience, Washington State Department of Health
"To me, innovation goes beyond developing the latest and greatest piece of technology, especially in public health where often our funding is limited. It's more about accepting that innovation can really happen anywhere at any time and at any level starting at the individual level all the way up to the larger more complex system like the public health system that we're a part of."
- Mimi Kothari, Health Scientist, Office of Readiness and Response, CDC
Policies and Funding
Successful innovation often involves exploring diverse funding streams and creative financing solutions. Public health agencies could look beyond traditional funding sources, leverage public-private partnerships, and explore shared services models.
Challenges and Barriers
To overcome significant challenges, agencies could focus on changing organizational culture to embrace calculated risk-taking and learning from failure. Leaders could work to create safe spaces for experimentation and innovation, recognizing that while not every new idea will succeed, each attempt provides valuable lessons.
"Public health faces immense public and media scrutiny, obviously now more than ever in any of our careers since the pandemic, and that scrutiny is a deterrent to trying something new because, depending on how disruptive a potential innovation can be, that innovation will potentially bring with it a high risk of failure."
- J.T. Lane, Senior Vice President of Population Health and Innovation, ASTHO
Collaboration and Partnerships
Building diverse partnerships are crucial for driving innovation in public health. Potential partnerships could include private sector companies, academic institutions, and community organizations. These partnerships bring fresh perspectives, additional resources, and knowledge sharing opportunities. For example, major retailers have a great interest in supporting robust public health programs that can combine public health expertise with private sector reach and efficiency.
"CVS Health has a great interest in having a robust community health worker program. We've partnered to discover innovative and promising practices in community health worker programs in both public health settings and in health plan settings."
- J.T. Lane
Tips for Implementing and Scaling
Several strategies can be implemented to foster and sustain innovation:
- Create a culture that accepts failure as part of the innovation process.
- Build diverse advisory boards to guide innovative efforts.
- Implement shared services models where appropriate.
- Measure both process and impact metrics to demonstrate value.
- Start with small pilot projects and iterate based on feedback.
- Dedicate time and resources for staff to engage in innovative thinking.
APPLYING THIS KNOWLEDGE TO INFECTIOUS DISEASE
The principles of innovation discussed can be particularly valuable in addressing infectious disease challenges. Here is how these concepts can be applied:
- Embrace a broader definition of innovation: In infectious disease control, innovation is not limited to new technologies. It can include new processes, communication strategies, or collaborative approaches.
- Foster a culture of innovation: Creating an environment where new ideas are welcomed, and failure is seen as a learning opportunity can lead to more creative solutions in infectious disease prevention and control. This cultural shift can encourage staff at all levels to contribute innovative ideas.
- Encourage cross-disciplinary collaboration: By breaking down silos and fostering partnerships across different sectors and disciplines, infectious disease programs can benefit from diverse perspectives and new approaches to long-standing challenges.
- Prioritize adaptability: Cultivating an innovative mindset can help programs stay agile and responsive to new threats or changing circumstances.
- Implement iterative approaches: Applying the concept of starting small, testing, and refining can allow infectious disease programs to innovate more effectively and efficiently.
- Balance innovation with evidence-based practice: While embracing innovation, it is crucial to maintain a commitment to scientific rigor. This balance can lead to approaches that are both creative and grounded in solid public health principles.
- Measure and learn from innovation efforts: Applying process and impact metrics to innovation initiatives in infectious disease control can provide valuable insights for continuous improvement and help justify ongoing innovation efforts.
This section encompasses a collection of pertinent tools and resources curated from ASTHO's Public Health Innovations Catalog and various other sources to help you navigate and comprehend the intricacies of this subject area. Garner insights and experiences from your peers, enabling you to start building solutions tailored to your health department.
Feeling inspired to address the unique challenges facing your department? With just one click, you can better understand your department's specific gaps and craft a persuasive action plan to present to your leadership and partners.
or explore the other focus areas:
Workforce Training & Resources Data Systems & Management Equity
Email the preparedness team with questions or comments.