Effective recruitment strategies are crucial and intricate for state and territorial health departments, particularly in the context of public health emergencies. The interplay of increasing public health demands and a rapidly evolving workforce landscape necessitates robust and adaptable recruitment practices. However, these departments often face substantial challenges, including stringent educational requirements, difficulties attracting high-quality professionals, and perceived inequities, complicating this process.
Despite these hurdles, it is important to acknowledge that state and territorial health departments are not isolated entities. Their shared experiences across jurisdictions, sectors, or programs can provide invaluable insights. These collective narratives reveal common recruitment challenges, underscore successful strategies, and, most importantly, inspire solutions. Recruitment should not be considered merely a logistical task but a transformative endeavor involving shifts in workforce development, innovative recruitment methodologies, and operational changes to attract and retain the right talent.
By exchanging experiences and learning from one another, state and territorial health departments can transform challenges into opportunities for enhancement, thereby ensuring their recruitment strategies remain dynamic, resilient, and aptly equipped to meet the shifting demands of public health emergencies.
As public health entities endeavor to navigate the complex terrain of workforce recruitment during public health emergencies, they encounter a range of challenges. A plethora of factors contribute to these obstacles, often compromising the effectiveness and efficiency of their recruitment strategies. From stringent educational prerequisites to difficulties attracting a high-quality workforce, these issues highlight the urgent need for innovative recruitment approaches that can adapt to the changing landscape of public health.
Common contributing factors to these challenges include:
history_edu
Educational requirements: High educational prerequisites for various positions can significantly restrict the pool of potential workers. This may limit public health organizations’ ability to recruit from a diverse range of backgrounds, potentially stifling innovation and hindering their capacity to address public health issues from multiple perspectives.
group_add
Attracting quality workforce: The competitive nature of the job market, coupled with the demanding environment of public health work, often makes it challenging to attract high-quality professionals. Health departments may need to take a multifaceted approach that includes competitive compensation, meaningful work, and supportive work environments in order to recruit effectively.
balance
Perceived inequities: Prospective recruits may be deterred by perceived inequities within public health organizations, such as discrepancies in the ability to work remotely or differences in pay scales. Transparent and fair policies can help address these perceptions and improve recruitment.
things_to_do
Political climate: The politicization of public health can negatively impact recruitment efforts. Negative public attitudes, often fueled by misinformation or misunderstandings about public health, can deter potential recruits from pursuing careers in this field. Clear and effective communication about the value and importance of public health work can help counteract these effects.
These challenges underline the pressing need for innovative and adaptable recruitment strategies that can help health departments navigate these obstacles and build a strong, diverse, and resilient public health workforce.
This section highlights a successful and innovative solution your peers implemented to address challenges with workforce recruitment. This story presents the factors that catalyzed the innovation, the existing policies or funding mechanisms that facilitated action, the potential barriers the agency faced, the collaborations and partnerships the agency leveraged, and tips for implementing and/or scaling the solution.
Innovating Public Health Recruitment: Harnessing Partnerships during COVID-19
Introduction
In response to the amplified necessity for a well-equipped and agile public health workforce due to the COVID-19 pandemic, distinct programs were launched in New York state and Region IV, a southeastern U.S. area encompassing eight states. These initiatives, namely the New York State Public Health Corps (NYSPHC) and the Region IV Public Health Training Center (PHTC), aimed to fortify workforce capacity and bolster readiness for future public health emergencies.
NYSPHC, established in 2021, is a pioneer program devised to recruit and deploy up to 1,000 fellows. These individuals, chosen for their diverse expertise in fields such as nursing, allied health, healthcare, social services, communications, information technology, logistics, planning, education, data science, emergency health, and public health, are positioned within the New York State Department of Health, local health departments, or other public health system partners. This strategy ensures that a wide range of professionals is available to address the varying needs of communities throughout the state. The fellows, in turn, work on various public health projects related to COVID-19, food insecurity, and wastewater surveillance.
In a parallel vein, the Region IV PHTC launched the Pathways to Practice Scholars Field Placement Program. This initiative, responding to the urgent call for a reinforced public health workforce, aimed to instill public health scholars with a thorough understanding of the intricacies and practicalities of public health work.
Both NYSPHC and PHTC have designed robust placement and professional learning support policies for their participants. Those accepted into the NYSPHC program are concurrently enrolled in the Cornell University Public Health Essentials Certificate Program, a 3-month online training that covers fundamental public health principles and key skills for practice. This certificate, valued at $3,600, is provided free of charge to NYSPHC fellows. On the other hand, scholars in the Region IV PHTC program are awarded a stipend to complete a 12-week field placement within a public health agency.
Challenges and Solutions
Despite the evolving landscape of public health and its various challenges, both programs have made strides in providing dynamic, comprehensive recruitment and training schemes. Through their diverse practical placements and structured academic opportunities, these scholars can acquire the real-world experience and theoretical grounding essential in this field.
Collaboration and Partnerships
Both programs’ successes are deeply rooted in the productive partnerships established with various health departments, public health agencies, and academic institutions (such as Cornell University). These collaborative relationships aim to enrich the learning experiences for the fellows and scholars, enhance their skill sets, and augment their ability to serve their communities effectively.
Tips for Implementing and Scaling
NYSPHC and PHTC share the following tips based on their innovative recruitment strategies:
- Partner with educational institutions: Collaborate with universities or other educational institutions to provide further training and certification programs. This will enhance the recruits’ skills and increase the program’s appeal, attracting a wider range of professionals.
- Recruit diverse candidates: Aim to recruit professionals from various fields related to public health to ensure a wide range of expertise and create a holistic approach to public health challenges.
- Provide flexibility in positions: Offer both full-time and part-time positions to accommodate professionals in different stages of their careers, making the program accessible to a larger pool of potential participants.
- Incorporate Hands-on opportunities: Provide real-world experience by deploying fellows in health departments or other public health agencies. This allows them to apply their knowledge practically, accelerating their professional growth.
- Provide continuous learning opportunities: Encourage continuous learning by working on projects or assignments addressing current public health issues. This keeps the recruits engaged and growing in their roles.
- Provide stipends or compensation: To attract high-quality professionals, ensure competitive participant stipends or salaries.
- Establish secure funding: Seek diverse funding sources, which might include federal and state allocations, grants, or collaborations with private sector partners. This will provide financial sustainability for the program.
- Plan for scalability: Start with a pilot program and refine the process and structure based on feedback and results before scaling up to cover more extensive areas or more considerable public health challenges.
- Incorporate community involvement: Engage the community and local health departments in the process. This ensures that the program meets local needs and builds strong relationships within the community.
- Focus on equity: Prioritize initiatives that promote health equity, addressing the needs of underserved and vulnerable communities. This aligns with broader public health goals and increases the program’s impact. (Check out the New York State Public Health Corps and the Pathways to Practice Scholars Field Placement Program for more information.)
APPLYING THIS KNOWLEDGE TO INFECTIOUS DISEASE
The New York State Public Health Corps and Region IV Public Health Training Center initiatives have significant implications and benefits for infectious disease practice and policy:
- Enhanced workforce capacity: By recruiting and training a diverse range of professionals in public health-related fields, these programs increase the overall capacity of the public health workforce, which is critical for efficient infectious disease surveillance, prevention, and response.
- Infectious disease response: The NYSPHC fellows work on various public health projects, including those related to COVID-19. The on-the-ground experience and training they receive directly contribute to improved infectious disease response.
- Epidemiological skills development: The initiatives described in the story foster an understanding of the practicalities of public health work, including core epidemiological skills crucial for infectious disease tracking and control.
- Preparedness for future emergencies: These programs focus on preparing the public health workforce for future emergencies, enhancing capacity for a rapid and effective response to future infectious disease outbreaks.
- Interdisciplinary approach: By recruiting professionals from various fields, these programs encourage an interdisciplinary approach to infectious disease policy and practice, which is crucial for addressing complex infectious disease challenges.
- Real-world experience: The field placement programs provide the scholars with practical, real-world experience, allowing them to apply their classroom-based learning to professional settings. This experience is crucial for effective infectious disease policy implementation.
- Collaborative partnerships: The successful partnerships with various health departments, public health agencies, and academic institutions can serve as a model for other states. Such partnerships can lead to more effective, coordinated responses to infectious diseases.
- Focus on equity: By prioritizing initiatives that promote health equity, these programs contribute to reducing health disparities, which can be particularly pronounced during infectious disease outbreaks. This aligns with current infectious disease policy goals aimed at ensuring equitable access to prevention and care resources.
- Continuous learning opportunities: By working on different projects or assignments that address current public health issues, the recruits are better prepared to adapt to the ever-evolving landscape of infectious disease practice and policy.
This section encompasses a collection of pertinent tools and resources curated from ASTHO's Public Health Innovations Catalog and various other sources to help you navigate and comprehend the intricacies of this subject area. Garner insights and experiences from your peers, enabling you to start building solutions tailored to your health department.
Feeling inspired to address the unique challenges facing your department? With just one click, you can better understand your department's specific gaps and craft a persuasive action plan to present to your leadership and partners.
or explore the other focus areas:
Workforce Training & Resources Data Systems & Management Equity
Email the preparedness team with questions or comments.